Mamdani Represents Existential Threat

The following editorial was originally published in the Honolulu Star-Advertiser on Sunday, November 2nd as part of the “Raise Your Hand” column in the Insight section.

By: Kala’e Kong, Saint Louis School


Amid the relative quietness of Hawaii’s political landscape, the most consequential election of this year is one over 5,000 miles away: the New York City mayoral race. It’s a three-man race among Democrat Zohran Mamdani, Republican Curtis Sliwa and former New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo who is running as an independent.

What distinguishes this election historically, however, is the looming victory of Mamdani, a self-proclaimed democratic socialist. Mamdani’s ascendancy is emblematic of a troubling drift toward socialism among younger generations and portends serious consequences for the rest of the nation.

The growing acceptance of socialism isn’t surprising. According to a recent Cato Institute survey, 62% of those aged 18-29 held a favorable view of socialism. This raises the question: Why does socialism appeal to young people?

The central reason stems from an underlying frustration with the many inequalities that exist in the world. Whether it be housing unaffordability, high cost of living, or the persistence of poverty, all of these problems reinforce young people’s disillusionment with the current state of the nation. The natural idealism of young people, which is both a blessing and a curse, creates a yearning for a better world. As noble as this is, when certain realities are not acknowledged, such idealism turns into naivete.

Perhaps the best example of this lies in the lamentable ignorance of socialism’s track record. As the historical record makes clear, every major socialist experiment – the Soviet Union, Maoist China, or Venezuela – has resulted in complete misery and the suppression of individual freedom. Throughout the 20th century, about 100 million people died under various socialist and communist regimes, according to estimates from the Hudson Institute. So while it may seem tempting, socialism’s equitable intentions belie its catastrophic record.

All of this isn’t to say that a Mayor Mamdani would inevitably lead the country into totalitarianism. That would be hyperbole. However, the consequences would be pernicious. A Mamdani victory risks legitimizing socialism in our nation’s politics, and as a result, more democratic socialists will become emboldened to run for public office.

Although this election is confined to New York City, Hawaii is not immune to its potential ramifications. Given the Democratic Party’s stronghold in Hawaii, whatever happens to the party nationally may eventually trickle down to the state. This necessitates an understanding of the current ideological battle happening within the Democratic Party. The contest between Andrew Cuomo and Zohran Mamdani best encapsulates the battle between moderates and far-left progressives. With the latter continuing to gain prominence, how long will it be before democratic socialism reaches Hawaii?

Mamdani’s ascendancy shouldn’t be dismissed as a mere historical anomaly. The alluring promise of “free” things will always capture the imagination of those most susceptible to its spell. For example, Mamdani’s proposals to create government-run grocery stores and institute rent freezes are what have driven his popularity. Not only is this financially infeasible, but it’s incompatible with the fundamental economic truth laid out by Milton Friedman: There is no such thing as a free lunch.

Socialism’s rise is not inexorable, but it will take active efforts to stop its meddling fingers from encroaching on the nation’s ethos. Take the 1948 presidential election between Harry Truman and Thomas Dewey. While those two defined the race, many overlook the third-party candidacy of former vice president Henry Wallace. Backed by the American Communist Party and a defender of Soviet policies, Wallace represented a threat to the nation and was rightly repudiated by Democrats and Republicans alike. One can only hope that the same shall become of Mamdani.

Related Articles

Sept. 10 marked a devastating day for our nation. An unparalleled American leader was

tragically and unjustly murdered for speaking his beliefs. A father, husband, mentor, leader and

Christian — Charlie Kirk embodied all these roles and more. His death deeply impacted not only

his family and supporters, but countless others, who drew encouragement from him. Even in his

passing, Charlie’s life continues to serve as an inspiring example that we can all learn from.

View More

When I first stepped into Puʻuhonua O Waiʻanae, a village of more than 250 houseless

individuals near the Waiʻanae Boat Harbor, I expected to see hardship. What I didn’t expect was

to find community, leadership, and above all, family.

View More

How many times have you picked up your phone today? If you’re like most people, the answer is

roughly 96 times, or once every 10 minutes. For teenagers, the numbers are even more alarming.

Teens spend over seven hours on their phone per day on average, according to Common Sense

Media.

View More

We all have something we just don’t get. Maybe it’s car maintenance or writing a decent

essay. Whatever it is, it often becomes an unnecessary source of shame. For many senior

citizens, that “thing” is technology. While this might seem like a harmless or inevitable

generational gap, the reality is more serious: Our kupuna are falling behind because they don’t

have the support they need to keep up in an increasingly digital world.

View More

Newsletter

Get the latest updates on how we create Hawaii’s next chapter

Sign Up for Our Newsletter
Sign up For Our Newsletter